History Hoydens


Historical Romance Writers Dishing the Dirt on Research

11 January 2011

Rediscovered Favorites

Last spring, I came into some unexpected money from my writing. (Many thanks to the Thai people for finding their way to my historicals through my vampires!) I was so stunned that I kept an ancient promise to myself: I bought the top series written by a favorite author, someone so long forgotten that she doesn’t appear on any social networks, is nearly invisible on eBay, and her Google hits are, well, slim.

Elswyth Thane (1900-1984) was a romance author, screenwriter and the wife of Dr. William Beebe, the great naturalist. (Yes, the books came after her marriage.) Her experience in the theater and his world influence some of her works. But more important, she loved history.

I bought her backlist with the found money because I’d read my copies to shreds. I could quote scenes. I went to places she’d written about and I looked for the people, events, buildings. She could sum up a character in a few lines, or even a phrase.

Elswyth Thane is one of the very authors who’s managed to field both alpha and beta heroes that I adore. I’m always fascinated by her ability to find the “telling detail,” even in the most romantic scene.

Here are two scenes where the hero finds his true love. The first is from the end of DAWN’S EARLY LIGHT, where Tibby has literally followed Julian to the American Revolution’s Carolina battles, just to be close to him.

As he rode he heard behind him the triumphant huzzah of the British infantry charge. A wounded Continental rose from the ground almost under his horse’s feet and caught at the bridle.

“Get to the rear, you fool!” Julian shouted, trying to control his rearing horse. “The surgeons are at Green Spring, you know that as well as I do! No, I can’t help you, make for the rear, man, there is a bayonet charge coming!”

The soldier went on shouting back something which was inaudible in the battle din, until Julian’s glance followed the man’s pointing finger. With an exclamation he swung out of the saddle to kneel beside the crumpled thing on the ground.

“How did this happen, I left him with the surgeon – he had no business to follow me –” Speech died in him. Under his hand, as he pushed back the open waistcoat and shirt to expose the wound, was the small white breast of a girl, with a slow crawl of blood across it.

“Tibby!” Julian gathered her into his arms and stood up, holding her against him. “Oh, my Tibby, I should have known!”

The second scene is from the beginning of EVER AFTER, set during Queen Victoria’s Diamond Jubilee summer of 1897. Aristocrat Bracken Murray is cynical and world-weary, after his wife leaves him for another man – until the very young Lady Dinah Campion is thrown from her horse in front of him.

“You look sort of green around the gills,” said the choir-boy’s voice. “Did it give you a nasty turn when I went off?”

“It did. I’m frightened out of a year’s growth. Look.” He held up one hand in mid-air, making no effort to control its visible trembling. His heart labored unbearably in his side, there was a thin singing in his ears. He had received some sort of cosmic shock, which he tried to use for her benefit. “You can’t lunge about the countryside scaring people to death like this,” he said, still speaking as though he had entered a cathedral during service. Not sixteen yet, you blithering fool, it’s against the law, his own thoughts ran – never mind, I can wait – two more years – three, perhaps – Lord, it will take me that long to get into the clear myself – I can wait – but not forever –

“Well, don’t take it so hard, I’m all right,” she said unsympathetically.

EVER AFTER is the third in Elswyth Thane’s Williamsburg series of novels and is a brilliant, sun-filled story. THE LIGHT HEART, the fourth in the series, is its darker counterpart and takes the family saga up into World War One. I always dither over which book I prefer. EVER AFTER is pure joy but I love the character in THE LIGHT HEART. Every one of the main characters – Phoebe, Oliver, Rosalind, and Charles – are utterly real and completely dear to me. I agonize over their dilemmas and understand their choices, even when I’m crying. Thane’s understated portrayal of Oliver and Charles’ friendship, two British officers supporting each other during bitter crises at home and war, eternally amazes me.

Not all of her books are autobuys, especially outside the Williamsburg series. Also, any new reader has to be prepared for her rather one-sided depiction of Nazis and the German people. (In my opinion, she wrote about contemporary events where they were the enemy, i.e., World Wars One and Two. Everyone has their blind spots – and her individual German characters are very multi-dimensional.)

So I’m blissfully happy I rediscovered my old favorite. Now I’ve started a wish list of other authors I still remember and want to explore more deeply.

Are there any old favorites you’d like to rediscover? Any authors you still learn from?



Blogger Lauren Willig said...

Hi, Diane! Although I gripe about technology, it does make it easier to rediscover old favorites. Last year, I finally tracked down Anne-Marie Selinko's "Desiree", a (very fictionalized) version of the life of Napoleon's first love. It was even the same edition I had read back in the day!

There must be a nostalgia bug biting.... Smart Bitches has a post up today about favorite Old School Reads.

8:20 AM  
Blogger Pam Rosenthal said...

Desiree was the book that gave me my start! I was 11, and found it oh so sexy and thrilling.

9:35 AM  
Blogger Meg McNulty said...

I'd replace all my Georgette Heyers and then get a full set of Stella Riley novels (the Marigold Chain is as rare as hen's teeth) - the hard cover version goes for £110 on amazon!

11:22 AM  
Blogger Diane Whiteside said...

Isn't Desiree wonderful, Lauren? Finding a book like that is almost enough to make you clear space for a whole new computer beastie.

Pam - Did you too start out by reading Desiree back in the day? Wow! Didn't that book just make you want to wrap yourself in history?

OMG, £110 for a hardcover edition, Charity Girl! Yowza! I too would trade in all my Heyers for Stella Riley in that case. I speak as somebody with 2 copies of The Silver Devil (in mass-market), because that masterpiece can run $100 on eBay. Good luck indulging your passion!

3:23 PM  
Blogger GladysMP said...

I must admit that I have never heard of Elswyth Thane before, but an author that I recall so belovedly is Mark Twain. I was so disappointed recently when I read where they have reworded Mark Twain's writing to make it politically correct. I think you should leave a writer's work alone...accept it as it was written.

4:34 PM  
Blogger Louisa Cornell said...

Oh my goodness! I hadn't thought of Desiree in YEARS! I must find my old hardbound copy and reread it. It has been over 40 years since I read it!

7:03 PM  
Blogger Isobel Carr said...

I found four of Candice Hern's old Regencies at a UBS yesterday . . . I bought them all!

11:57 AM  
Blogger Isobel Carr said...

I think you should leave a writer's work alone...accept it as it was written.

Couldn't agree more (and you'll note that they left "Injun Joe" alone, and "Injun" is every bit as offensive to Native Americans as the "N" word is to African Americans).

11:58 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

I love Elswyth Thane! She was the second or third romance author I ever read back. Tryst! So un-PC and so sweet and romantic.

2:08 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Free Web Site Counter
Kennedy Western University Online